Skip to main content

Khan v Maidana is power vs power

Phil D. Jay
WBN Editor

There’s a lot of talk, especially in the United States, of the forthcoming Amir Khan vs Marcos Maidana WBA light-welterweight title fight on Saturday night being a battle of Khan’s speed against Maidana’s power.

The fight at the Mandalay Bay Hotel in Las Vegas has even adopted the same name as Floyd Mayweather’s 2005 showdown with Italian-born Canadian legend Arturo Gatti; 'Thunder vs Lightning' as the promoters try to make the fight accessible to the American public.

For my money, the bout should be called Thunder vs Thunder as Amir Khan has demonstrated his awesome power on numerours occasions in the past and it's just something that the American audiences have yet to witness.

Granted that Maidana has 22 wins of his 29 contests, finishing in the first three rounds to Khan’s 12, but Maidana has fought six times more than Khan and its questionable whether his class of opponent could be compared to that of the former Olympic Silver Medallist.

Khan stepped up to Commonwealth Title level after only 13 bouts, stopping Willie Limond over eight rounds as a 21 year-old, a feat beaten by the experienced Erik Morales recently by only two rounds, which shows the level of Khan’s foe’s from an early age.

Five months later, Khan blasted Graham Earl out in 72 seconds, something a 27 year-old Michael Katsidis couldn’t manage as Earl retired after five rounds, ten months prior to taking on “King Khan.”

In his thirteenth fight and fourteenth fights, Maidana was still knocking out club fighters, with 18, 12 and 8 defeats on their record and learning little from his class of opponents until his stepped up in class against Andriy Kotelnik in 2009 and suffered his first defeat.

The fact that Khan despatched Kotelnik in dominant fashion five months later, should have the alarm bells ringing in the Argentinean’s head, as I believe that Khan has as much if not more power in both hands, whereas Maidana seems to rely a lot on his right.

It is true that Khan has a suspect chin and if he does get caught by Maidana, it will be interesting to see what happens if it’s a flush shot. But all in all, I believe that Khan has the better technical boxing skills and combined with his speed, he will make more openings for power punches than the interim champion.

I will stick my next out and say that Khan will stop the Argentinean within six rounds and propel himself onto the cusp of the pound for pound rankings, with the Bolton man being only a unification victory away from breaking the top 10.

Khan v Maidana is live on HBO from 9.30pm and Sky Box Office from around 2am on Saturday night into Sunday morning the 11th/12th December.


Popular posts from this blog

The Tragedy of Billy Collins Jr.

Phil D. Jay WBN Editor  Collins after the fight Williams Ray Collins Jr. or Billy Collins Jr. as he became known, was born to a boxing father in Antioch, Tennessee in 1961. His father William Sr, once fought Welterweight Champion Curtis Cokes and wanted his boy to follow in his footsteps, so decided to train Billy himself. Collins Jr. turned pro in 1981, a welterweight, just like his father before him and impressively won his first 14 professional contests, 11 by knockout with eight inside the first three rounds. It was 1983 and Billy was matched up against Puerto Rican journeyman Luis Resto on the undercard of Roberto Duran v Davey Moore at Madison Square Garden in a ten rounder. Resto wasn’t known for his punching power but Billy took a sustained beating for the full ten rounds, his face, badly damaged and his eyes were almost shut. After the fight, which Resto won on decision, Billy’s father shook Resto’s hand and noticed there wasn’t much padding in his gl...

The Ring Magazine P4P Top 10 compared to WBN's P4P Top 10

World Boxing News pound for pound Top 10 (25/11/2011) 1. Manny Pacquaio (53-3-2) WBO Welterweight champion and WBC light-middleweight champion 2. Nonito Donaire (26-1) WBC and WBO bantamweight champion 3. Floyd Mayweather Jr (41-0) 4. Bernard Hopkins (52-5-2) WBC and IBO light-heavyweight champion 5. Juan Manuel Marquez (52-5-1) WBA and WBO lightweight champion 6. Miguel Cotto (36-2-0) WBA "Super" light-middleweight champion 7. Sergio Martinez (47-2-2) 8. Wladimir Klitschko (55-3-0) WBO and IBF heavyweight champion 9. Pongsaklek Wonjongkam (80-3-1) WBC flyweight champion 10. Chris John (44-0-2) WBA “super” world featherweight champion Do you agree or disagree? Have your say on the WBN Facebook wall at  http://www.facebook.com/pages/World-Boxing-News/134654593225151

WBN Remembers: "Gypsy Boy" Ernie Smith

Phil D. Jay WBN Editor  (picure by boxrec.com)  After almost a year and a half without one of boxing’s great journeymen, World Boxing News is looking back at the 161-fight career of Worcestershire warrior Ernie Smith, concentrating on his contribution in the ring, rather than the tragic way his life ended out of it. Smith turned professional at super-featherweight in 1998 at the Park Hall Hotel in Wolverhampton, losing a six rounder against Welshman Woody Greenaway.  One month later, Ernie was thrown in with an unknown prospect by the name of Gavin Rees (former world champion and current British Lightweight Champion) who he also took the distance over four rounds. The “Gypsy Boy” then managed to string together a four fight unbeaten run together in early 1999 and ended the year winning five out of his twelve contests, but by this time had already delved into the journeyman pool of boxers with a record of 5-8-1. After settling at the welterweight limit, Ernie ga...